YNAB vs. EveryDollar vs. Mint: Which Budgeting App Reigns Supreme (Now That Mint’s Gone)?

Mint’s dead. YNAB costs money. EveryDollar has Dave Ramsey’s ghost in the machine. Feeling lost trying to find a budgeting app that actually helps you get ahead? I hear you.

After 25+ years helping folks wrestle their finances into submission, I’ve seen which tools build real wealth and which just track the slow bleed. Let’s get straight to what really works in 2025.

If you’re serious about getting your financial house in order, picking the right budgeting app is like choosing the right weapon for a battle – and trust me, managing money can feel like a battle.

If you’re just starting out, you might want to understand the Benefits of Budgeting Why Important before diving into specific apps.

The Big Three: Core Philosophy Differences – How They Think About Your Money

It’s not just software, it’s a money mindset. Are you planning your financial attack. Or just counting the casualties after the spending battle is over?

This is where these apps fundamentally diverge.

YNAB: The Proactive General – Giving Every Dollar a Job

You Need A Budget (YNAB) isn’t just a clever name; it’s a command. Their core philosophy is proactive budgeting.

Before you even think about spending a dime of your income, YNAB demands you “give every dollar a job.” This means you allocate all your expected income to specific categories. From rent to that sneaky coffee habit.

It forces you to be forward-thinking, planning your expenses meticulously rather than just looking back at what you’ve already spent. It’s about intentionality.

Back in February 2023, I worked with a tech consultant whose cash flow was about as organized as his sock drawer. Introducing him to YNAB was like handing a pilot a flight plan after years of flying by instinct.

YNAB isn’t just about “giving every dollar a job”. But about rewiring how you think about money from the ground up.

Want a bold prediction? By 2026, AI-powered categorization in YNAB will be so precise you’ll know what your future self regrets buying—before you even click ‘buy now.’ Is your budgeting app coaching you, or just tracking your bad habits? That’s the question.

EveryDollar: The Disciplined Drill Sergeant – Zero-Based & Debt-Focused

EveryDollar, backed by Ramsey Solutions, marches to the beat of zero-based budgeting,. Heavily influenced by Dave Ramsey’s financial teachings (you probably know him for the Dave Ramsey 7 Baby Steps).

Similar to YNAB, it’s proactive. You plan where every single dollar will go at the start of the month, ensuring your income minus your outgo equals zero.

“A budget isn’t about restricting what you can spend. It gives you permission to spend without guilt or regret.”

– DAVE RAMSEY

The big emphasis here is often on aggressively tackling debt and following Ramsey’s structured plan for financial peace. It’s about discipline and following a proven system.

Zero-based budgeting is a discipline, not a default. Plenty of folks abandon it the minute life throws a curveball. My hot take? By the end of 2025, more people will use zero-based frameworks as a “reset button” after financial setbacks, not as a lifelong routine. Ever tried keeping your spending at zero when your roof starts leaking? Apps don’t mop up the water.

Mint (The Ghost of Budgets Past): The Reactive Historian

Mint, bless its defunct soul, took a largely reactive tracking approach. Its main strength was hoovering up all your past transactions from linked accounts, categorizing them (sometimes correctly, often not), and showing you fancy charts of where your money had already gone.

You could set budgets, but it was more of an afterthought. Mint was great for a financial autopsy; less so for preventative medicine.

Did you know: over 7 million Mint users migrated to “Credit Karma Money” or old-school spreadsheets within 60 days of shutdown? Why? Because inertia dies hard, and change is scarier than bad data. Who’s helping you chart a new course, not just tally up the wreckage?

Feature Face-Off: YNAB vs. EveryDollar vs. Mint (Legacy)

Enough philosophy, let’s talk brass tacks. What do you actually GET with these things, or what did you get with Mint?

Note: EveryDollar Premium is part of Ramsey+. Pricing for Ramsey+ can vary based on promotions.

The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly: Strengths and Weaknesses

No app is perfect. I’ve seen clients thrive with one and flounder with another. Here’s where they shine, and where they just… don’t.

YNAB: The Powerhouse with a Price Tag

• YNAB Advantages:
  • Superior Budgeting Methodology: Their four rules genuinely change financial behavior. It’s not just software; it’s an education. I had a client, let’s call her Sarah, who was drowning in credit card debt despite a good income. Six months with YNAB’s discipline, and she was not only out of the red but had a clear plan for her future. It forced her to confront her spending in a way no other app had.
  • Reliable Account Synchronization: Fewer sync headaches than Mint ever had.
  • Complete Category Customization: Tailor it perfectly to your life.
  • Proven Savings: YNAB claims users save $600 on average in their first two months and $6,000 in their first year. If true for you, that $109 annual fee is a bargain. (Source: YNAB.com – claim often cited on their site).
  • Responsive Customer Support & Active Community: They invest in helping users succeed.
  • Continuous Platform Evolution: They’re always refining and adding useful features.
• YNAB Limitations:
  • Subscription Cost: That $109/year is a hurdle for some, especially if you’re already feeling broke.
  • Steep Learning Curve & Time Commitment: This isn’t a plug-and-play app. You need to invest time understanding the methodology. If you’re looking to just start YNAB in the middle of the month, there are ways, but it highlights that initial setup requires thought.
  • Less Comprehensive Financial Overview (than Mint was): While it tracks net worth, its strength isn’t being an aggregator of all financial data like Mint aimed to be (e.g., investment performance details are basic).

EveryDollar: Simple Strategy, Ramsey Rules

• EveryDollar Advantages:
  • Straightforward Zero-Based Budgeting: It’s simple to grasp, especially if you like clear directives. If you want to learn how to create a spending plan or budget without complex rules, this is a good starting point.
  • Robust Free Version (for manual budgeting): If you don’t mind inputting transactions yourself, the free version is excellent for implementing a zero-based budget.
  • Motivational Framework (Baby Steps): For those following Dave Ramsey’s plan, the integration is seamless and motivating. I had a young couple, Mark and Lisa, who were overwhelmed by student loans. The Baby Steps structure within EveryDollar gave them a clear path, and they celebrated every milestone.
  • User-Friendly Interface: Generally easier to pick up for basic budgeting than YNAB.
  • Strong Debt-Reduction Focus: It excels at helping you organize and attack debt using methods like the debt snowball.
• EveryDollar Limitations:
  • Bank Syncing Behind Paywall: This is a big one. Automatic transaction import only comes with the paid Ramsey+ subscription.
  • Basic Reporting in Free Version: You get the basics, but not deep financial insights without paying.
  • Can Feel Restrictive if Not a Ramsey Follower: The app strongly nudges you towards the Ramsey way. If you have different financial philosophies (e.g., on credit card use or investment priorities), it might feel confining.
  • Credit Card Handling: While you can track credit cards, its approach is more about avoiding them, which differs from YNAB’s more nuanced “use credit cards like debit cards” system.
  • Customer Support: Generally good, but sometimes more geared towards the Ramsey methodology than complex, niche technical issues.

Mint (What We Learned from Its Heyday & Demise):

• Mint Advantages (When Operational):
  • Completely Free: No subscription fees were its biggest draw.
  • Easy Setup: Minimal learning curve to get started tracking.
  • Comprehensive Financial Overview: Its dashboard aimed to show everything – bank accounts, credit cards, investments, loans, and property values for net worth tracking.
  • Credit Score Monitoring & Bill Management Features: Added value for a free product.
  • Broader Bank Compatibility (Initially): It synced with a vast number of institutions.
• Mint Limitations (That Ultimately Led to Its Downfall):
  • Persistent Synchronization Problems: This was the #1 complaint for years. What good is tracking if the data is wrong or missing?
  • Limited Budgeting Capabilities: It was never a true proactive budgeting tool.
  • Ad-Supported Model Cluttered Interface: The recommendations and ads could be intrusive.
  • Poor Customer Support: Getting help was notoriously difficult.
  • Stagnation & Eventual Shutdown: Intuit clearly deprioritized it over time, eventually leading to its closure in March 2024.

“Michael, Which One Should I Choose?” – User Recommendations

Alright, decision time. No more fence-sitting. Let’s match you with your money soulmate (or at least a decent roommate who doesn’t steal your leftovers).

Understanding the benefits of budgeting why important is the first step, choosing the tool is next.

Go with YNAB if You:

• Are dead serious about fundamentally changing your relationship with money and your spending habits.
• Need help with debt reduction or have aggressive saving goals and want a rigorous system.
• Prefer reliable software with responsive, top-notch support and are willing to pay for premium functionality.
• Can commit the time and effort to learn a new, powerful budgeting methodology.
• Are comfortable with technology and want deep customization.
• Michael’s clincher: “If you treat budgeting like a critical mission to transform your finances, YNAB’s your command center. It’s an investment, not an expense, if you use it right.”

EveryDollar is Your Best Bet if You:

• Are a fan of Dave Ramsey’s Baby Steps or want a clear, simple, guided path to financial control.
• Want a solid free option for manual zero-based budgeting and are disciplined enough to enter transactions yourself.
• Are primarily focused on getting out of debt and appreciate a motivational framework built around that goal.
• Prefer simplicity and a very straightforward user experience over a ton of bells and whistles.
• Want your budgeting tool to align with a broader ecosystem of financial education content (Ramsey+).
• Michael’s clincher: “If you want a no-frills, opinionated coach to get your spending in line, especially if you’re on the debt-free journey and like Ramsey’s style, EveryDollar makes a lot of sense. The free version is a great way to dip your toe into zero-based budgeting.”

Since Mint is Gone, Consider These Alternatives if You:

• Simply want to track where your money went and see an overview of your accounts (more reactive than proactive).
• Prefer free solutions, even if they come with limitations or ads.
• Want a comprehensive financial account overview, including net worth tracking and possibly credit score monitoring, with minimal time investment in active budgeting.
• Michael’s options: “Intuit is pushing former Mint users towards Credit Karma. It focuses on credit scores, tracking, and financial product recommendations. It’s okay for a financial snapshot.
  Other free trackers exist, but none were quite the Mint of old in terms of account aggregation. For a simple, free, manual budget, EveryDollar’s free tier is a strong contender.
  Or, you can go old-school with a good old spreadsheet – I even have an article on the Cash Stuffing Envelope Budget method, which is zero-based budgeting with physical cash.”

The Verdict: Planning Your Future vs. Documenting Your Past

So, who wins the YNAB vs. EveryDollar battle, especially with Mint out of the picture? That depends entirely on what game you’re playing with your money.

YNAB and the premium version of EveryDollar are about active financial planning. They empower you to control future financial outcomes through intentional, proactive budgeting. Mint, and many free trackers like Credit Karma, are more about passive money documenting – showing you the crime scene photos of your past spending.

Look, Mint showed you what happened. YNAB and EveryDollar hand you the detective kit and the training to prevent the financial ‘crime’ in the first place. YNAB is the full FBI academy of budgeting, teaching you a deep, flexible methodology. EveryDollar, particularly its free version, is like a focused bootcamp for getting spending under control with zero-based principles, and its premium version adds the full Ramsey training regimen.

The annual cost for YNAB (around $109) or Ramsey+ (around $80, including EveryDollar Premium) becomes a rounding error if their methods click for you and you achieve the kind of savings they promote. YNAB offers a 34-day free trial (or similar, check their current offer). EveryDollar has that excellent free version to get started with manual zero-based budgeting.

My thoughts? Give one of these proactive systems a genuine try. What have you got to lose besides debt, financial stress, and wondering where your money went? The power is in the planning, not just the tracking.

• Sharing the article with your friends on social media – and like and follow us there as well.
• Sign up for the FREE personal finance newsletter, and never miss anything again.
• Take a look around the site for other articles that you may enjoy.

Note: The content provided in this article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial or legal advice. Consult with a professional advisor or accountant for personalized guidance.